February 5, 2020 brainstorm

From Zack's Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Image of whiteboard taken at the end of brainstorming session, held with Costis on February 5, 2020.
Image of whiteboard taken at the end of brainstorming session, held with Costis on February 5, 2020.

system maintainers / custodians:

  • mindset
    • digital
    • analytical
    • integration
    • obsessive / meticulous
    • think as patterns
      • "data as data"
      • "grammar", structured info
  • natural language
    • expertise in generalized patterns
    • knowledge of knowledge
    • stepping back, to see the big picture
  • digitalization of observations
    • transformation into computable data structures
    • with purposes of:
      • storage
      • transmission
      • processing
      • analysis
      • visualization
      • archive / keep for posterity
      • etc
    • supportive roles / structure maintainers
    • are often control freaks

normative archaeology

  • Archaeological toolbox
  • Common terms, notions and concepts
  • Common 'weighting' of ideas, knowledge of what 'counts' or should be taken seriously
  • ability to consider multiple hypothetical pathways, given different sets of assumptions or approaches
    • ability to shift between these tracks, group between sets

kinds of agency

  • creative
    • decisive
    • based on experience implementing
    • intuitive
  • supportive / enablers
    • sets up environment to facilitate implementation
    • understand value of work in a superficial way
    • foster a sense of will
  • routinized / automation
    • implementers
    • respond to / [unclear] creative direction
    • those who integrate their experiences with prior knowledge/experiences (i.e. build/gro their skillset/potential) will become intermediaries rather than mere novices

tool/activity selection / strategy

  • potential effectiveness of tasks dependent on understandings of:
    • the available materials
    • the possibolities and limitations that the materials afford (knowledge for)
    • the methods that may be implemented to express/attain those possibilities given the materials (knowledge that <--> knowledge how)
    • by [creative] agents in decision-making roles)
  • will to adopt, recognition of value
  • comparison of tools, cost/benefit analysis
  • scoping, defining boundaries, specifically regarding possibilities and potential
  • projection, speculation about potential outcomes
  • recognition of people's work, assemblage of symbols or stereotypes associated with roles or activities
  • recognizing domains under which work can be assigned, based on recognition of skillsets and designated roles

research questions

  • what are the factors that contribute to the tensions between information systems people and <archaeologists> in terms of how to maintain data effectively?
  • how does the distribution of labour relate to the implementation of information systems?
  • how are epistemic values <inscribed> into <archaeological> practices, especially those that relate to the pragmatic aspects of knowledge curation?